Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Microsoft GitHub Disables youtube-dl Open Source Project

Microsoft GitHub Disables youtube-dl Open Source Project


The open supply undertaking youtube-dl is likely one of the finest instruments to obtain movies from YouTube and lots of different video internet hosting web sites.

However the existence of this undertaking is beneath risk proper now. Recording Trade Affiliation of America, Inc. (RIAA) despatched a discover to GitHub towards youtube-dl and its forked repositories on 23 Oct 2020.

Microsoft owned GitHub complied instantly and inside 24 hours, the official youtube-dl and its forked repository had been disabled as DMCA takedown.

Microsoft GitHub Disables youtube-dl Open Source Project

What’s a DMCA takedown?

DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) is a US copyright legislation relating to copyright and the web.

If the rightful proprietor of content material (video, audio, textual content) believes {that a} sure webpage is utilizing (or enabling others to make use of) the content material with out authorization (infringing upon the rights of the content material proprietor), the proprietor can ship a DMCA takedown discover to the internet hosting service.

Upon receiving the DMCA takedown discover, the internet hosting service could disable/delete the webpage (or whole web site).

There’s additionally a provision of counter discover the place the opposite get together can problem the takedown.

RIAA’s letter towards youtube-dl

As per the letter despatched by RIAA, it accuses youtube-dl of infringing upon the rights of its members. It accuses youtube-dl:

“The clear goal of this supply code is to (i) circumvent the technological safety measures utilized by licensed streaming companies similar to YouTube, and (ii) reproduce and distribute music movies and sound recordings owned by our member firms with out authorization for such use. We be aware that the supply code is described on GitHub as “a command-line program to obtain movies from and some extra websites.””

The letter mentions how the GitHub repository of youtube-dl mentions that it’s a program for downloading movies from the YouTube.

The README of the youtube-dl had talked about downloading movies of Justin Timberlake, Taylor Siwft and so forth within the command utilization examples. That has additionally been used within the discover to make a case towards youtube-dl.

Microsoft’s GitHub thought of/transformed the letter right into a DMCA discover and disabled youtube-dl and seventeen different repositories talked about within the letter.

John Bergmayer, Authorized Director at Public Information, says that it’s not an assertion that youtube-dl is an infringing work however the RIAA declare is that it’s unlawful.

This isn’t actually a DMCA request. I don’t see an assertion that youtube-dl is an infringing work. Reasonably the declare is that it’s unlawful per se

— John Bergmayer (@bergmayer) October 23, 2020

What lies forward for youtube-dl?

The youtube-dl workforce ought to certainly file a counter enchantment as a result of they don’t seem to be serving copyright content material to the customers straight.

However they need to guarantee a few issues:

  • Contemplate altering their title and take away youtube from it in order that they’re secure from copyright discover from Google (proprietor of YouTube) sooner or later.
  • They need to not point out any examples of their repository that demonstrates downloading of a copyrighted video from YouTube.
  • Put up a discover that onus of downloading movies lies on the person and discourage them from downloading copyrighted movies. That is one thing Linux torrent shoppers like Transmission already do.

Initiatives like youtube-dl have to reside

youtube-dl is utilized by many different instruments and web sites to offer the power to obtain movies from YouTube and different video internet hosting web sites.

This will sound like piracy however which may not be the case on a regular basis. Some video creators make their movies obtainable beneath Artistic Frequent license in order that others can use this work.

Downloading such copyright-free movies via youtube-dl shouldn’t be an issue.

Many individuals throughout the globe have restricted web connectivity. Downloading academic movies in order that they will check with it later with out spending bandwidth is a real use of such a software.

Was it truthful to takedown youtbe-dl?

I’m shocked on the swift motion taken by Microsoft GitHub on this case. They chickened out so simply.

Think about a bunch of DMCA trolls begin sending takedown notices to different initiatives on the pretext of copyright. It is a risk. Keep in mind how a patent troll tried to extort cash from GNOME’s Shotwell picture viewer program.

I do hope that the youtube-dl workforce counters the takedown and doesn’t give into the strain.

I do know that it’s an open supply undertaking and its code may be hosted on a GitHub different web site like GitLab. Nonetheless, RIAA is a robust group and so they can strain different code internet hosting web sites to take away youtube-dl repositories once more. The repeated takedowns may additionally demoralize the builders into abandoning the undertaking.

I’ve at all times puzzled why YouTube doesn’t permit the video creators to have the power to make their movies obtainable for obtain both totally free or for a price.

What do you consider your complete episode? Do you suppose the takedown is true? Do categorical your views.


You May Also Like


The latest round of MITRE ATT&CK evaluations proved yet again that Microsoft customers can trust they are fully protected even in the face of...


On Thursday, April 23rd, 2020, Canonical Ltd, the makers of Ubuntu Linux distribution officially released the long-awaited Ubuntu 20.04 version code-named “Focal Fossa”, it...


As the robot process automation (RPA) market becomes more and more dynamic, more and more companies are trying to integrate RPA into their business...


Virtual Machine Manager is one of the best hypervisors available for the Linux desktop. This is well-designed and well-functioning QEMU/KVM virtualization software that takes...